However, a nonanthropocentric utilitarian approach to environmental ethics only broadens the set of morally relevant organisms to include, in addition to humans, elephants, cetaceans, great apes, and a handful of other sentient organisms. In this lesson, we explore the perspective of ecocentrism within environmental ethics, defining and explaining both concepts. Deontological ethical theories tend to focus on doing whats right and on moral duties, principles, rules and rights, largely independent of consequences. And obviously, environmental ethics takes up ethics in considering what moral obligations humans have to nonhuman nature. Environmental ethics an overview sciencedirect topics.
Overview environmental ethics is a subdivision of professional and applied ethics that concerns itself with the responsibilities that we. Having a homosexual bias or basis 2005, the advocate number 947, 27 september 2005, page 62 with this years onslaught of homocentric networks, queer television programs for 2005 literally run the entire gay gamut. I examine three approaches to environmental ethics and illustrate them with examples. Take, for instance matthew hall, he believes plants are sentient beings. Environmental ethics says that one should base their behavior on a set of ethical values that guide our approach toward the other living beings in nature. In both fields, numerous books and articles about cases have appeared, including book length catalogs of cases. Biocentric, homocentric, and theocentric environmentalism in. Nonanthropocentric ethics grants moral standing to such natural objects as animals, plants and landscapes.
In addition to theories of normative ethics that construct moral. Environmental ethics starts with human concerns for a quality. For homocentrists, the environment only has value insofar as it is useful to us. Learn environmental ethics with free interactive flashcards.
The homocentric ethic holds the good of the human species above other values discussed in gardner and stern, 1996. Homocentrism holds that only humans have intrinsic value. Apr 12, 2020 this extract comes from a chapter on normative ethics in a book on environmental philosophy. The environment has no value of its own, only that which is derived from its value to humans. This book describes the slow but absolute poisoning of the. It emphasizes social justice rather than individual progress. Environmental ethics offers an uptodate and balanced overview of environmental ethics, focusing on theory and practice. First, humans centered and life centered systems of environmental ethics, second, the good of a being and the concept of inherent worth, third, the attitude of respect for nature, fourth, the justifiabiliy of the attitude of respect for nature, fifth, the biocentric outlook on nature, sixth, humans as members of the earths community of life, seventh, the natural world as an organic system, eighth. We also explore some of the early ecocentrists and highlight issues. What follows is a copy of chapter 8 of the revised edition of my book ecological ethics. With this distinctive proposition in mind, curry introduces and discusses all the major concepts needed to understand the full range of ecological ethics.
The book will be valuable for students taking courses in environmental philosophy, and also for a wider audience in courses in ethics, practical ethics, and environmental studies. Environmental ethics involves the moral basis for environmental responsibility and how far this responsibility extends. A more homocentric or shallow ecology approach focuses on the worth of the. Environmental ethics and political conflict a view from california. There are several qualities about each ethical system. Biocentrism is a philosophical and ethical premise that all living organisms should be considered as equals. Environmental pragmatism is an approach that focuses on ethics rather than policy. Carolyn merchant, environmental ethics and political. A homocentric ethic is grounded in society and is based.
A groundbreaking work that moves the tourism debate forward applies moral concepts to tourisms most challenging issues draws on a broad field of crossdisciplinary research into ethics tourism ethics applies moral concepts and issues to some of the most vexing tourism dilemmas of the day, through foundational research from many disciplines including biology. Environmental ethics this research will be based on two types of theories. Seligman 1989 discusses environmental ethics from a more philosophical. Biocentrism, ethical perspective holding that all life deserves equal moral consideration or has equal moral standing. In his article, the nature and possibility of an environmental ethics, tom regan says that the fitting attitude toward nature is one of admiring respect. According to the world health organization, the warming of the planet caused an additional 140,000 deaths in 2004, as compared with the number of deaths there would have been had average global temperatures remained as they were during the period 1961 to 1990. It is wishful thinking to believe that well just pack up camp and regress somewhat in order to allow the environment to heal, as nice as that does sound to my conscience.
Utilitarianism is one of the prominent approaches to. In anthropocentric or homocentric ethical approaches, the environment or at least parts of it. Alasdair cochrane london school of economics and political science a. In this lesson we compare this to the anthropocentric viewpoint that places humans at. Whilst challenging at times, the variety of papers in terms of both interdisciplinary and difficulty is wide, allowing readers to effectively engage. This essay will demonstrate different approaches to environmental ethics, andfocus on the effects yielded on the environment as a result of humansselfishness. In his view, there is no need for a fundamentally new ethics as our traditions are sufficiently rich to teach us that all. Egocentric, homocentric, ecocentric, and multicultural and partnership ethics are 4 different ways to look at the environment and how to use it. These views can be broadly grouped into two approaches. The closest approach to reconciliation between these schools of thought comes from utilitarianism, which is largely anthropocentric in its approach, but believes that animal pain is a moral consideration.
In merchants book she describes four ethical paradigms, these are the process that individuals view the environment from their viewpo. Topics include conceptual approaches in ethical theory and ecological philosophy, such as deep ecology and ecological feminism as they pertain to such environmental issues as environmental education and. Anthropocentrism is the belief that human beings are the most important entity in the universe. Responding to the profound awareness of environmental crisis which prevails in this closing decade of the 20th century. The book describes three different values or ethics, egocentric, ethic, homocentric, and ecocentric, but i am going to be focusing on the last two.
Crafting an environmental ethic in or for a new unit of geologic time is utterly. Environmental ethics is the branch of bioethics which deals with questions pertaining to mans relation to nature. What foliows is an attempt to discover what in nature should impel us to respond in this way. They think environment as an immediate surroundings of individuals that the individuals need to adapt to, or control. Environmental ethics is an established field of practical philosophy which reconstructs the essential types of argumentation that can be made for protecting natural entities and the sustainable use of natural resources. As a reaction to anthropocentrism, other ecophilosophers disagree, however, saying that we have direct responsibilities to natural objects other than human beings. Breaking it down, biocentrism is the theory that all living things have equal and inherent worth, relating to the concept deep ecology. Environmental ethics ethics seeks to define what is fundamentally right from wrong, regardless of culture. The main competing paradigms are anthropocentrism, physiocentrism called ecocentrism as well, and theocentrism. Ebscohost serves thousands of libraries with premium essays, articles and other content including biocentric, homocentric, and theocentric environmentalism in o pioneers. It is not an antihuman argument nor a putdown of those seeking social justice.
An egocentric ethic is grounded in the self and based on the assumption that what is good for the individual is good for society. The book describes three different values or ethics, egocentric, ethic, homocentric. Ecocentrism is not an argument that all organisms have equivalent value. Although elements of biocentrism can be found in several religious traditions, it was not until the late decades of the 20th century that philosophical ethics in the western tradition addressed the topic in a systematic manner. Carolyn merchant, environmental ethics and political conflict. This chapter is the fullest treatment in the book of ecocentric ethics as such, and includes some discussion of leopolds land ethic, gaia theory, deep ecology, left biocentrism and the earth manifesto as well as earth ch. This field is characterised by a wide variety of approaches, some of which will be discussed in this chapter. Environmmental ethics exerts influence on a large range of. These theories will be the guiding approaches that will be used in order to come up with the real issue at hand and also be able to provide a solution for the same. The requirement for environmental ethics to move beyond sentience as criteria for inclusion in the moral realm is discussed in regan. Aug 24, 2012 this book explains the basic concepts of environmental ethics and applies them to global environmental problems.
Carolyn merchant examines the major philosophical, ethical, scientific and economic roots of environmental problems and identifies the ways in which radical ecologists can transform science and society in order to sustain life. According to the world health organization, the warming of the planet caused an additional 140,000 deaths in 2004, as compared with the number of deaths there would have been had average global temperatures remained as they were. An ecocentric ethic is grounded in the cosmos, or whole environment. Agriculture is having a lasting effect on this planet. In addition, it willdeepen further to the fundamentals of how the humannature relationship should flow in order to preventpossible exploitation. For a good summary of environmental ethics as it relates to land use planning i recommend reading chapter 7 of the book on land use ethics by timothy beatley ethical duties to the environment. Environmental issues are frontpage news from storage of. One of the central areas of philosophy is ethics, the study of what is the right thing to do. Because utilitarians recognize only the intrinsic value of pleasure or desire satisfaction, the commitment to intrinsic value in environmental ethics has also driven a rather deep wedge between environmental ethics and the ethics of utilitarianism. An introduction to environmental philosophy introduces you to ethical theory in new and easily understood ways. Kosho niwano argues that religious leaders must make an appeal to society about environmental ethics. Environmental ethics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In merchants book she describes four ethical paradigms, these are the process that individuals view the environment from their viewpoints.
Start studying ecology and environmental science chapter 2. The author, carolyn merchant, described three forms of ethics egocentric, homocentric, and ecocentric. Free essay sample on the given topic utilitarianism is the best approach to environmental issues. Homocentric approach is grounded at utilitarian ethics and social level. Written by academic experts with 10 years of experience. From the beginning, and emerging during a time of environmental crises, environmental ethics has worked to link theory and practice. In this thoroughly revised and updated second edition of the highly successful ecological ethics, patrick curry shows that a new and truly ecological ethic is both possible and urgently needed. Chapter 7 of the book on land use ethics by timothy beatley ethical duties to the. Casebased environmental ethics cases have been widely used in medical ethics and law. Four ethical paradigms described in merchants book philosophy. Environmental ethics is about including the rights of nonhuman animals in our ethical and moral values. Biocentrism is most commonly associated with the work of paul w. It will also appeal to general readers who want a reliable and sophisticated introduction to the field.
Hays main concern, in the light of an antigreen backlash, is that homocentric democracy is insufficient for the achievement of the ecocentric goals having a homosexual. An example of homocentric approach is epidemiology. In some parts of the world, what you are doing is already apparent. Utilitarianism is the best approach to environmental. Dec 18, 2012 first, humans centered and life centered systems of environmental ethics, second, the good of a being and the concept of inherent worth, third, the attitude of respect for nature, fourth, the justifiabiliy of the attitude of respect for nature, fifth, the biocentric outlook on nature, sixth, humans as members of the earths community of life. Historically associated with govemment regulation of the private sector, a homocentric approach can be illustrated by federal, state, and local environmental agencies charged with protecting the welfare of the general public. And, for instance, the book the power of ethical management by ken. The term can be used interchangeably with humanocentrism, and some refer to the concept as human supremacy or human exceptionalism.
Business must develop and demonstrate environmental moral leadership. The first views nature as socially and economically valuable because of the benefits for humans. Id use an ultimately homocentric approach, but preach that in order for the true protection of the environment, a compromise must be reached between the camps. In particular, ethics is concerned with value judgments. Environmental ethics is the discipline in philosophy that studies the moral relationship of human beings to, and also the value and moral status of, the environment and its nonhuman contents. However, with environmental issues, this is not the case, as we saw with garret hardins tragedy of the commons.
Which of the following best matches the description. Egocentric, homocentric, ecocentric, and multicultural and partnership ethics are 4 different. Robert elliot discussed humancentred, nonhumancentred and consequentialist environmental ethics before this section and virtuebased environmental ethics afterwards. But it stands aside from these smaller, shortterm issues in order to consider ecological reality.
It does not deny that myriad important homocentric problems exist. Choose from 500 different sets of environmental ethics flashcards on quizlet. Those of you that have read about nature ethics and conservation are probably familiar with the two principal points of view, the humancentered or homocentric, and the naturecentered or ecocentric. John benson, another ethicist, describes this problem in his book environmental ethics. I argue that pluralistic casuistry provides an adequate approach to environmental ethics. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Robin attfield, in his book the ethics of environmental concern 1983, 11 claims that christianity is much richer than authors like white and passmore presume. By classical accounts, ethics is people relating to people in justice and love. Written in clear and engaging prose, the book provides an historical perspective on the relationship between humans and nature and explores the limitations and possibilities of classical ethical theories in relation to the environment. Ethics, he suggests, has traditionally been most concerned with human beings as subjects and objects of doings, rather than with the environment 10. Anthropocentrism interprets or regards the world in terms of human values and experiences. Anthropocentrism is considered to be profoundly embedded in many modern human cultures and conscious acts. But most of all, this environmental ethics textbook shows you how we can work together to build a better future. This anthology of some 64 readings includes excerpts of works by philosophers and nonphilosophers and classical as well as contemporary writings. Each person takes their own ethical idea for their life in order to justify and improve their position in life. Hall argues that plants should be considered sentient beings, just like paul taylor. This book explains the basic concepts of environmental ethics and applies them to global environmental problems. All of us, whose lives are supported by this miraculous planet earth, need to think about what we can and should do to protect the earths environment, so that all of us can continue to live here. In the book, egocentric ethic was grounded in the idea that what is good for the individual is good for the society.
One key approach to environmental ethics focuses on the moral status, and ethical treatment, of individual animals. Ecocentrism project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Unit for environmental ethics, university of stellenbosch article type. Coverage includes philosophical ethics and environmental public policy, the environment in western thought from the bible through thoreau, aesthetic and. Deontological environmental ethics environmental responsibility. The author concisely introduces basic moral theories, discusses how these theories can be extended to consider the nonhuman world, and examines how environmental ethics interacts with modern societys economic approach to the environment. Most commonly, moral status is attributed on the basis of animals subjective. Pdf business and environmental ethics researchgate. The ethics of environmental ethics 936 words 4 pages. Environmental ethics takes up aesthetics insofar as it concerns questions about the beauty of nature. Environmental ethics introduction garrett hardin april 21, 1915 september 14, 2003 was an ecologist and his 1968 essay the tragedy of the commons also was an important text in establishing the background for the development of the. Environmental ethics holmes rolston, iii environmental ethics is theory and practice about appropriate concern for, values in, and duties regarding the natural world. Ecological ethics tim madigan asks, what is the right attitude to take to all life. Environmental ethics environmental ethics is the discipline in philosophy that studies the moral relationship of human beings to, and also the value and moral status of, the environment and its nonhuman contents.
1467 13 1218 416 1458 936 130 381 940 1192 63 1440 331 1531 1424 558 801 217 1545 1541 1386 37 104 115 21 1309 937 347 485 1414 1345 837 1397 1094 1441 205 753 1220 30